Thursday, April 23, 2015

"Click" and the Experience Machine

Jack Forde


Click is a very average Adam Sandler film based on a character who suddenly acquires a magic remote that enables him to “fast forward” and through many of the tumultuous points in his life. Sandler’s character, Michael, is a very hardworking architect and often works long hours to try and advance his career and provide a very good life for his family. Michael often sacrifices time with his family for work and seems to not be able to say no to his boss. Michael is given a magical remote by a shady fellow named Morty in the “Beyond” section of a Bed, Bath, & Beyond. He soon finds that the remote allows him to control time and he is able to go back and revisit events from his past and fast-forward through parts of the future.
            This is related to Robert Nozick’s thought experiment the “Experience Machine” where individuals are able to enter a much more pleasurable simulated reality. This experiment is an attempt to refute hedonism and show that some things other than pleasure (or sheer bliss) have value and increase one’s well-being. While the thought experiment is very enticing and enables one to picture what type of life they would be able to have in this “virtual reality,” Nozick aims to refute the notion that happiness is the only thing of value by pointing out that most people will not “plug in” (or in this case, “click in”) even if they could. Nozick states that people want to actually do things, not just experience them and that these experiences are just a byproduct of one’s accomplishments. He also goes on to talk about how people want to be in control of their own life and not be held to a man-made reality. Individuals also want to be people of virtue and use the lessons learned from past experiences and hard work to result in more accomplishments.
            The movie Click relates to Nozick’s Experience Machine and helps to refute the theory of hedonism because Sandler’s character starts to realize that as he fast-forwards through time, his body is on "auto-pilot" - his mind skips ahead, while his body goes through the motions of everyday life. As the movie goes on, the remote starts to fast-forward without Michael controlling it. Michael's various attempts to dispose of or destroy the remote fail, so he resolves to change his life so that the remote can't control him. This part of the movie is in line with one of the arguments against the Experience Machine (and therefore against hedonism) in that the person “plugged in” to the machine cannot possibly change the course of the pre-set experiences, so an experience that was once seen as potentially full of happiness is now one that the person finds melancholy. The person also has no control of the future situations and is now at the mercy of the experience machine (or in this case, the magic remote).
            The theme of the movie and the underlying notion of Nozick’s idea is that all experiences in life matter and that sometimes the bad experiences in one’s life are some of the most instrumental. These experiences are not good within themselves but should not be overlooked. The “experience machine” or the magic remote cannot (in theory) be programmed to help individuals learn these lessons from tough moments or allow individuals to change preferences over time. Michael learns that while he has great ambitions to become successful professionally, it is his wife and kids that will bring him genuine happiness. The moments that he “fast-forwarded” through, often became pivotal moments in his life where he learned some valuable life lessons.  This movie is an example of how moments of “pure bliss” can be outweighed by very real, often tough moments in life. We do not always know for certain what exactly it is that we want from life and moments where we learn valuable lessons are sometimes the most valuable.
           

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BOuby0cSa0I

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.